Innovative Teaching Methodologies and India

E-mail Print PDF

Authored By Satwinder Singh:

How many times has it happened that you had to stifle a yawn, with the same old banal comment-‘It’s just too boring’, during class hours? If the scenario sounds familiar- Welcome to the World of Modern education. You will be at least pleased to know that you are not alone in this respect. Most of the students (in schools and colleges alike) complain that their classes are way too insipid, and that their teachers are unable to express themselves properly, thus failing to make the class interesting for them. India is facing an acute faculty shortage problem. It is estimated that there is a shortage of over 10 lakh teachers, just in the school level. Moreover, 1 in every 3 teaching post in the IITs lies vacant. There are over 7 lakh un-trained teachers in elementary schools across the country. As a result, the Gross Enrolment Ratio of India is a paltry 12.4(which means that out of 100, just 12 students manage to complete their schooling), compared to 25 in China, and around 70 in Developed countries such as England or France. If the teaching methodology itself is flawed, there is very little incentive for a child to continue attending classes.

The Sarv Shiksha Abhiyaan(SSA) and the Mid-day Meal schemes, though quite munificent, have failed to achieve their mark beyond an introductory level. Though the enrolment rate in villages has improved, it is seen that many students drop out of school before they reach Class 8. Government schools are mere dilapidated buildings, with bare minimum infrastructure, and the attendance of students is more than that of teachers. Even the poor people are now sending their children to private schools, in the hope that they can find a suitable job, and settle down amicably in some place. Anyways, the Government is trying to provide succor for the needy. Let us focus a bit on college (or higher) education, which has vastly remained a nescient sector. Barring the top colleges, such as the IITs, JNU, DU, JU, etc, the quality of education provided in most institutions, has remained stagnant, or has deteriorated. Although India has the highest number of Higher Educational institutes in the World (above 20,000), quality-wise we lag far behind almost all major countries.

 

Not a single Indian Educational Institute features in the top 100 Global List. Plus, due to the strict bureaucratic norms, setting up campuses in India, for foreign institutes has become quite onerous. Globalization in education is virtually non-existent in India. Now, we return to our main topic- the Teaching Methodology followed in Higher Educational Institutes, mainly colleges or universities. The system followed by most institutes is the same- Appoint some part time and full time faculty members to take lectures, say of 1 hour duration or more. Most of them stick to what is given in the book and refuse to look beyond that. They impart mere theoretical/bookish knowledge, and are the least bit concerned about the welfare of the student. Hardly anyone bothers to make the class seem interesting. The reason for this is not because all teachers are sadistic (that is just a rumor), it is mainly because of two factors. One, most of those lecturers never wanted to be one in the first place- They were forced to opt for teaching, since they did not get any job elsewhere. Secondly, and most important, most of them are highly under-paid(A Blue-Collar worker in a Government job can earn much more than a Lecturer in a Private Engineering college), and usually suffer from a so called inferiority complex. Why should they be concerned about the career of their student, when they feel that they have been unable to do anything about their own career? So they do what’s expected of them: ‘Go to class, blurt out anything for one hour or so. Scribble down something on the black board. Take a few tests, give the internal marks, and that’s all.’ As a result, it is the student who suffers. Frustrated by the vapid lectures, he becomes inattentive and restless. He starts execrating his subjects. Most of such lecturers have very poor communication skills. Even if they know their subject (which is a rarity in itself), they fail to express it properly in class. After a student loses interest, it is quite ostensible that he won’t study the subject or carry out any research work beyond the scope of the college syllabus. This is one of the reasons why India produces so few scientists of international renown or Nobel Prize winners. The Education system does not promote innovation or creativity. Rather, out-of-the-box thinking is derided by most. So what can be done in order to generate genuine interest for any subject in the student? First of all, entrepreneurship and creative thinking must be promoted. Students should be encouraged to come up and take up sumptuous projects, or research works promoted by the Professors. Teachers should try to understand the student’s mentality- they should read books on Student Psychology. Most students do not want to listen to dull, monotonous lectures which stretch on and on.

Teachers should give real-life examples of events. For example, if a teacher is Teaching Computer Science, he should give examples of the latest Super-Computers, Marketing techniques adapted by Microsoft, flaws of Windows 7, etc- even if those things are not included in the syllabus. Similarly, the teacher should give more stress on the application part, rather than forcing the student to memorize hundreds of pages from gargantuan sized text-books (which becomes redundant in any case). The theory portion taught should be kept succinct, and extra stress should be given on the practicals. Another solution is- Active Class Participation. The teacher should follow a Full Duplex Communication Mode- in Layman’s terms; he should involve students in the discussion, and not drone on about the topic. But this does not mean that the teacher should keep on asking redundant questions just to harass the student. He should encourage them to come forward, speak and participate, plus share their thoughts on the subject. Quizzes, Group Discussions, Elocutions, etc can be implemented in classes to make them more interesting. If there is a proper two way communication between the teacher and the student, then the later will never feel bored in class. Above anything else, the teacher must have a good sense of humor, or at least be quite tolerant. However, in the practical situation, we often see that most teachers loose their temper at the drop of a hat.  Many of them have the habit of disagreeing with the student, no matter what happens, in order to display their superiority.

A genuine teacher will never restrict himself to his own subject, or area of specialization. He will always delve into all aspects related with he teaches. He should give real life examples, the details of the Technical Part, the Managerial Aspect, or the Artistic touch, which will give more finesse to the subject. His communication skills should be impeccable. In all, the students should automatically come to attend his class, and should not do so out of compulsion or for attendance. There is no magic wand which can get rid of the flaws over-night. But if such sanguine methods are adopted by the teachers, we can certainly hope that they will obviate the torpor in students. By this, students will take interest in their areas of specialization and will come forward with innovative ideas for providing low cost solutions to existing problems. However, I must say one more thing- All this cannot happen without the Will of the student. Both sides have to give an incessant effort. The student has to co-operate with the teacher. And he must avoid all sorts of nefarious activities such as strikes or violent protests. There are many impediments which we may have to face. But as the saying goes, ‘Where there is a will, there is a way.’

Comments (21)add comment

Jayanta Bhattacharya said:

0
...
Absolutely bang on target.

"Barring the top colleges, such as the IITs, JNU, DU, JU, etc, the quality of education provided in most institutions, has remained stagnant, or has deteriorated."

Correct.

According to NASSCOM 75% of Indian engineers are unemployable mainly because they are products of sub-standard colleges, esp those privately run. Similar is the case with MBAs

Barack Obama has announced that the US needs to gear up to face the challenge put forward by the Indian and Chinese students in the field of science and tech in order to stay ahead in the race for development and advancement of scientific knowledge.

It was in a way calling for what I would term as 'Intellect Security' that is far critical than Energy Security or even Climate Security. In India, we may be producing graduates by the truckloads, but we are not building any Intellect Security for ourselves.

That is a matter of grave concern.
 
March 19, 2010 | url
Votes: +1

Aditya said:

0
...
Cannot agree with you more satwinder! I also feel students are not encouraged to take up Teaching as a Career. If a person wants to become a teacher he is hardly encouraged by people around him. Apart from a few good institutes very less stress is put on having a Post graduate courses in Teaching. Teacher should be more of a friend than resembling Hitler! I am optimistic about the youngsters getting into teaching ( Examples like teach for india) and changing the scenario. I hope it does!
 
March 20, 2010
Votes: +0

Satwinder Singh said:

0
...
@Jayanta: Yep, that's quite true. And I am even a bit apprehensive about the Brain Gain policy which the HRD ministry is trying to implement. We must focus on infrastructure development and quality of education to retain our brightest students.

@Aditya: Absolutely! For example, a Senior Professor at Harvard can earn more than an average businessman does in India. Indian teachers are amongst the most poorly paid people in the world. We cannot expect Impeccable teachers unless we(the Government) pay them well, and offer them amenities.
 
March 20, 2010
Votes: +0

Nancie Saputo said:

0
...
I stumbled onto your blog and read a few post. I like your style of writing.
 
March 21, 2010 | url
Votes: +0

twitter backgrounds said:

0
...
Hey, Awesome site you have here.

Keep up the good work!
 
March 22, 2010 | url
Votes: +0

Vanita Asante said:

0
...
I didn't understand the concluding part of your article, could you please explain it more?
 
March 30, 2010 | url
Votes: +0

Team Building said:

0
...
I am always searching online for articles that can help me. Thank you
 
April 02, 2010 | url
Votes: +0

Satwinder Singh said:

0
...
@Vanita:

What I wanted to say was that if some nice methods are adopted by the teachers to get rid of the dullness in students, it can help in the long term.

Only if a student is genuinely interested in his/her specialization, can we expect something innovative or creative from him/her. The student should co-operate with the teacher to do something productive- say a project which can help others.

I will give you one example- Have you heard of Vardan Kabra? He is an IIM-A alumnus, the creater of Fountainhead- An entrepreneurial venture that provides schooling for kids. That guy could have entered into a lush corporate job, but he gave it up to do something good for others- a pure altruistic act. We need such entrepreneurs in Today's India.
 
April 02, 2010
Votes: +0

Resless said:

0
...
@Satwinder: The mindset is sick...I used to learn French on a Social Networking site sometimes back and in due process i used to converse with a lot of guys from abroad.........i have a habit of asking 2 questions: 1 What do u do... and..2 Do u enjoy doing it

Trust me 99% of the ones that i met and who were teacher by profession said that they are so happy being teacher.....on the contrary if i happen to ask the same question to the ones here in India either online or in person...the answer that usually comes out is..Yeah going on somehow....no other alternative as well so m happy only.......lol

In a country like india..the common mindset is this that if u cudn't do anything and failed in all aspects that you gave a try then become either a teacher or a lawyer........This needs to be changed. On a closer scrutiny of this u shall conclude that our govt has also failed to give due respect to teachers.."

As long as u don't have teachers who are happy of being teachers u shall have no innovation and no methodologies

So the lesson is give birth to " Happy Teachers" smilies/smiley.gif

Keep the good work up, Man smilies/smiley.gif
 
April 03, 2010
Votes: +1

Satwinder Singh said:

0
...
@Resless: Exactly. Most people consider teaching as a last option. We have heard the popular saying-'We all want good teachers. But none of us want to become one.' So where will good teachers come from? They are not going to drop from the sky. People need to be given more incentives to take up teaching as a full time profession. smilies/smiley.gif
 
April 03, 2010
Votes: +0

Naveen K R said:

0
...
Really a nice article smilies/smiley.gif I think and feel girls should feel that teaching is a good profession and they should choose teaching because, that will make them independent, and ladies are more suited than man, because of their soft corner to kids compared to gents.
 
April 05, 2010 | url
Votes: -1

adisha said:

0
...
A well written article with a balanced point of view.

I still remember in college when teachers tried to teach electronics failing miserably since they were confused between marathi and english .

Also, I still remember my physics teacher in 11th who made physcis the most interesting subject in the world by using exampls from every day life.

India needs to go quite a distance before being able to achieve educational basics. The mid day meals are enjoyed by people too poor to afford food.

My grandfather in law had started a school in a room in Ropanchapra ( village in UP ) 2 decades ago for girls ( the first in the area ). Today it has expanded to become a building where the classes are till 12th now and the teachers are students themselves who teach there till they find a good job in the city.

It's said enough no. of times, but a major change is required in the eduactional requirments and instruction mechanism as well.
 
April 12, 2010 | url
Votes: +0

igbejerk said:

0
...
I read a article under the same title some time ago, but this articles quality is much, much better. How you do this?
 
April 17, 2010 | url
Votes: +0

boston catering said:

0
...
I found out your web site through google, i was surfing and ended up here, i like what i read, you have skill. For that I can appreciate you more then it may seem.

I'm not a specialist at many things.I don't know about politics,I'm no medic, I have no clue about animals, actually there are many things that i have no idea about...BUT..I'm a specialist at cooking, I'm a chef and my business is to make folks feel like in heaven every time they eat what i cook. Perhaps a wedding or a birthday party or whatever and whenever the reason might be. So how hard can be at times to make people feel better at times. That's why i like you!

There is also something that i enjoy, people blogs that educate other people on diffrent topics.
You're great! Thank You!
 
April 18, 2010 | url
Votes: +0

Mayy Tirumalai said:

0
...
Whilst looking bing I identified this webpage,

Reader's Quotient - Innovative Teaching Methodologies and India
. I should say I surely like it and can bookmark and arrive once more quickly.
 
April 22, 2010 | url
Votes: +0

Lisa Nachtsheim said:

0
...
Yes, couldn't agree a great deal more. And I'd prefer to add that you have obtained a tremendous colour plan in your website, I endure with colour blindness and a lot of webmasters do not give us a 2nd believed!
 
April 26, 2010 | url
Votes: +0

Akansha Agrawal said:

0
...
@Naveen
Hey! lets not get into the man-woman debate. It's about being a teacher, not a male or female!!
 
May 10, 2010 | url
Votes: +0

Dr. S. P. Mishra said:

0
...
It is true that the education and educational standard deteriorated a lot. There are few reason which lead to this deterioration.
1. Education sector, specially higher education sector practically became a neglected sector by the Government with the philosophy that higher education in USA is more self financed. This leads to development of private engineering colleges and it became a business.
2. IIT, JNU, DU maintaining their quality as because they are attracting more qualified teachers because of their finance position. etc financed.
3. Most of the State University are mismanaged and they put only primitive subjects with more load on theoretical and primitive papers. There is no scope created in the curriculum for more extra curricular activities that leads to personal development.
4. Maximum, not all students become job oriented than knowledge oriented. This created least interest for higher study, specially M.Tech and Ph.D. Few used to go for M.Tech on compulsion, if they are in teaching.
5. Most of the private colleges giving more stress on advertisement, and planned marketing activity rather than knowledge or academical activity.
6. With competition, few engineering colleges are paying at par with AICTE pay scales but always have the tendency to maintain the staff with minimum finance. This created job security problem for the teacher.
 
August 21, 2010
Votes: +0

Jenny said:

0
...
I didn't see a link anywhere but do you have advertising? I have several blogs in the same niche and I'd like to add my banner somwhere on your site. This site seems to have a lot of discussion and visitors.
 
November 08, 2010 | url
Votes: +0

Sunandan said:

0
It all begin from the basics
What I believe is that apart from the teacher's role of making a class interesting it is very important for the student to be interested to learn what the teacher is trying to convey. And frankly saying the student of India is not the one to be willing to do that in most general cases. The problem starts at the very basic level, because as a kid the preliminary education does not allows the kid to open up mind to imagination. Education to a kid is mostly a liability, whereas it should be something that is fun. And as obvious as it gets, if the kid is made into someone who is eager to learn end explore at the start itself he would make a fine student for sure and a better engineer, doctor or a scientist.
 
August 07, 2011 | url
Votes: +0

Harpreet Bhullar said:

0
...
I like your suggestions in the end and strongly feel that academicians have to think on these lines to make the course content more relevant and interesting.

But I could not understand why you would want to paint your classic teacher as an absolutely apathetic misfit professional who ia unable to gain interest of the class purely because of his own incorrect career choices. Because you have very articulately mentioned the universal problems of the education system in the beginning of your article. The putative "sub-standard" institutes if private, are also borne out of this unquenchable need of a certain few for inundating profits where meticulour aspects like "quality of teaching" is not really a concern of the significant persons of that institute. Before we comment upon the sub-standard educational institute's class room scene, we also need to look a little deeper at the very ideological foundation of that institute.

Further. many rural and sub-urban spaces are not blessed with institutes like D.U or J.N.U because of various political reasons and financial hiccups. Not just because the teacher standing in front of 40 pairs of eyes was not thoughtful enough while making a career choice.

I felt your situational analysis and recommendations are extremely insightful and significant but I felt while portraying the picture of a teacher you spoke from an outsider's view on the possible life-path of a person who just happened to be a teacher...
 
October 23, 2011
Votes: +1

Write comment

busy